Reviews

4.7
Based on 237 reviews
4.9
Based on 45 reviews
4.5
Based on 104 reviews
Rambo T.
Rambo T.
Always great food and really kind people.
Janine G.
Janine G.
the pizza here is especially good. we really enjoy all the food and the complimentary zeppolis are fantastic! highly recommend
Nicole
Nicole
The hot honey pizza is to die for!!!! Ordered take out a few times and their pizza & sandwiches are delicious
Dan
Dan
I came in right before closing and ordered a personal pie to eat in. They were so nice and let me stay past close to enjoy my delicious pizza! They went even further by offering me zeppoles after i was done with my pizza making me feel welcomed like... family. Thank you!!read more
Anthony F.
Anthony F.
The pizza and entrees are the real deal. Traditional Italian cooking. Reasonable pricesAnd nice atmosphere
Caleb K.
Caleb K.
Penne with vodka sauce pizza was delicious, plus free dessert!
Hope O.
Hope O.
We have really enjoyed our experience with Forgia. We first tried the Meat Lover's Pizza and a Meatball Hero and dined in. The meatballs were flavorful and high quality. The sauce is amazing! My husband loved the Meat Lover's pizza. *FYI tips can't... be left on a credit card*Our second experience was take out last night. We ordered the garlic knots (HIGHLY RECOMMEND), the hot honey pizza, and Hawaiian pizza. We enjoyed the hot honey one the best out of the two. For those who don't have a high tolerance for spice, the hot honey has a hint of hotness, it's not extremely spicy. =) Oh and the garlic knots were warm, soft, garlicky, and the sauce is 5/5 stars amazing.We will be back!read more
Joe S.
Joe S.
Good food and service
Xavier O.
Xavier O.
This place has grown on me the past 2 years. We've only done take out, have yet to dine in. every time we've ordered it's been top notch pizza
Maria G.
Maria G.
We discovered this gem after a chiropractic appointment in Suffern. Hands down the best Margarita pizza ever! Then on our next visit to the area we tried a...
Chiffani P.
Chiffani P.
Pizza! Brick oven style, fresh with premium ingredients! We loved the “NY Classic & Porcinzola”…definitely recommend it!
Herder G. Rodríguez A.
Herder G. Rodríguez A.
My first time of many more to come. The place is neat, organized and clean with good vibes. Delicious pizza made with fresh ingredients and authentic Italian food. Fair selection of wines. Real brick oven pizza. A must go if you love pizzas.
Elba C.
Elba C.
Quick service..Outstanding personal pizza. Yummy, flavorful !!
Carlos padua J.
Carlos padua J.
Great Italian restaurant, the food is unbelievable.
Josephine R.
Josephine R.
Great food 😋 service and atmosphere 👌
Victor V.
Victor V.
Drove a whole hour for these garlic knots, hands down the best I’ve ever had
Larry S
Larry S
Pizza was delicious. I like thin crust, and it was thin. Even the crust was delicious, which I usually don't eat. The staff was very friendly even though they were very busy and the bill was reasonable. Well return if I'm back in the area.
Shannon C G.
Shannon C G.
Food was great, staff was so friendly. their garlic knots are INSANE!
Brian B.
Brian B.
Margarita with Fresh Tomato was really good. Crust was on target.
Richard K.
Richard K.
Absolutely love this place. So glad he decided to open up his restaurant in my hometown. Had never once had a bad meal there. Friendly clean always great...
Wendy D.
Wendy D.
I came here a few years ago. I just found some photos from this time. Overall it was a nice experience. I would go back again. The people seem very dedicated and respectful so it’s a nice 👍 place to go eat.
Mitchell D.
Mitchell D.
Loved the fried Zucchini and cavatelli and broccoli rabe and finished off with a cannoli and a cappuccino. a little piece of heaven
Aleks D.
Aleks D.
Great pizza and very friendly service.we enjoyed this place!
Hemish K.
Hemish K.
The pizza was crisp and delicious.The kids had a spinach calzone. They loved, remembered their manners and even said thank you for the delicious meal to the staff.We took a few cannolis to go.. they look great. I'm certain the taste will match..
Alexandra P.
Alexandra P.
The brick oven pizza was excellent. Prices are moderate. Nice place to eat before catching a movie.
LeRoy P.
LeRoy P.
Great thin crust, wood fire oven, pizza. Lasagna that makes momma proud. Some of the finest calamari I've ever eaten. Weekly specials like soft shelled crab. This place only gets better!
Andrew D.
Andrew D.
Great pizza and maybe even better food. Cooked in a wood burning oven, I have never had anything that disappointed. Chicken Parm is out of this world!
Nicole P.
Nicole P.
Pizza and service was very good!
Ned D.
Ned D.
Great mom and pop Pizzeria and more in Suffern’s downtown!
Marley B.
Marley B.
First time being there, pizza was fantastic, and customer service was good as well. I ordered a pepperoni pizza from the brick oven and it was really good....
Audrey
Audrey
Best pizza in town and also weirdly the spinach is amazing
juliana C.
juliana C.
Best pizza!! Love the spinach pizza sauce on the side!!!
Rosalie N.
Rosalie N.
UNBELIEVABLE the best fresh food ever. Choices are extensive. The sauce was close to Nana's. I had the lamb chops off of the special menu and they were great and served over a mound of sauteed broccoli rabe. You have to try this hidden treasure. It... is now one of our frequent restaurant. Clean and decorated beautifully.veryfreindly owner and service was top too.a must to try.read more
Jane W.
Jane W.
Pizza was great; service was good; interesting fried dough dessert like a good southern funnel cake.
Mary C.
Mary C.
The food was delicious, the atmosphere pleasant and the service exceptional. Highly recommend.M. Curry, Hawthorne, NJ
Atymez3
Atymez3
One of the best pizza places I've ever been to. The food is mad good and the staff is friendly and really take care of you. You can tell they have pride in their work and their establishment. If you're in Suffern, NY, you have to try them! I went 2... days and a row! Forgia knows food ! 5 stars baby!read more
Patrick R.
Patrick R.
Two words - Salad PieReally enough said with that, but since salad pie isn't for everyone...It's all in the dough. I imagine if you licked the brick...
Joseph Baratta and Company R.
Joseph Baratta and Company R.
Eggplant Parm is excellent. Pizza is very thin crust & well done.
Jared Rudnick (.
Jared Rudnick (.
My wife and I walked into downtown Suffern for an early Saturday dinner. She ordered spaghetti fra Diablo and I got chicken parm with spaghetti. The meals came out quickly, were huge, and delicious. The service was great even tho they were very... busy. The only downside was that you're unable to leave a tip on a card. The service was so good, and waitress so nice, we went to get cash and returned to leave a tip. So if you're gonna need to leave a tip, make sure you bring cashread more
Matcha D.
Matcha D.
Been there a couple times. This is a real bonafide pizza place. Real dough, real sauce and real cheese on everything.Whether it's a quick lunch or a nice dinner I highly recommend giving this place a shot.
RANDY C
RANDY C
Friendly Staff, Delicious Food, great Pizzas, oh man, the dinner rolls were amazing too! Definitely coming back! Try their special menu. We ordered combo seafood with squid ink linguini pasta. It was served with King Crab leg. Enjoyed it very... much!read more
Robert H.
Robert H.
Food and staff are amazing !
JK
JK
Excellent brick oven pizza and great service!
Erin L.
Erin L.
Food is awesome and the owner and staff always pleasant .
Jon O.
Jon O.
Love this gourmet style pizza, enjoyed it so much that I dream about it. Clean, friendly and expedited service.
Liz Duffy R.
Liz Duffy R.
food is so delicious and a really big menu with so many choices. cant wait to go back.
Edward M.
Edward M.
Excellent food, service and staff.
Eve M.
Eve M.
Delicious pizza. Even the gluten free crust which is not always easy to find in all restaurants is very crispy and tasty
Ana C.
Ana C.
Love everything from Forgia specially the Brick Oven Margarita Pizza, the Bronzini garlic fish, the caprese salad, the calamari etc.the staff: Victor and Camila and her husband are very, very nice!My family and myself are repeat customers and... we'll recommend Forgia to everybody.psthe house's merlot wine are so good!read more
Sky C.
Sky C.
Reviewing after over 6 visits this past fall: Never failed to impress us with their pizzas, etiquette, aptitude and willingness to please. May you prosper and serve the town well! Thank you.
Nash W.
Nash W.
I've tried SOOO many places here in NY trying to find a good pizza. Brooklyn, NYC, Bronx and now upstate. This is my first, and last, pizza place I will try.... I can tell you why... it's GREAT!!! I'm so spoiled by West Coast pizza but this was... awesome. First off I'd like you to see the picture of the garlic knots. Oh, wait, there is no picture because I ate them ALL before I got home!!! I could not stop. BEST GARLIC KNOTS OF ALL TIME!!! I ordered a large vegetarian pizza and when I opened the box I thought uh-oh.... thin crust... but it's really not. It was the perfect crust.... not cracker crispy but chewy the way a crust should be.... and with every bite I was extremely happy!! The toppings were fresh and plentiful. I will definitely order this again. Though next time a meat lovers pizza. The Zeppoles Were a nice finishing touch.The bottom line.... I drive 8 miles and 25 minutes to Forgia pizza, I suggest you make the effort! It is truly worth your time!!! I will return. I'm looking forward to surfing their entire menu.... because hey, if I'm stuck here in this.... ummm, hamlet, I might as well eat the very best2ND VISIT UPDATE: Ok.... I was almost hesitant to order the garlic knots again as I didn’t want to be disappointed, but I did and damnnnn if they still aren’t THE VERY BEST I’ve ever ever had! Again, gone before I arrived home. The meat lovers pizza with added heavy anchovies was almost completely destroyed as I could not stop enjoying it. I had the food baby from hell but enjoyed every minute!!Big fan!!! I’m going to try a few of their new pizzas next time.... they sound amazing too.Thank you Forgia pizza for making the weekend that fell apart soooooo much better!!!read more
Nash W.
Nash W.
Ok.... I was almost hesitant to order the garlic knots again as I didn't want to be disappointed, but I did and damnnnn if they still aren't THE VERY BEST...
Nash W.
Nash W.
I've tried SOOO many places here in NY trying to find a good pizza. Brooklyn, NYC, Bronx and now upstate. This is my first, and last, pizza place I will...
Paul M.
Paul M.
Great pizza and friendly staff and owner. Our go to Pizzeria.
Tony M.
Tony M.
Great place to eat. Takeout is good too.
Stuart B.
Stuart B.
The pizza was excellent..!!
Kiana G.
Kiana G.
Great personal pies! Got the vegetarian and added pepperoni for spicy-ness and it was awesome! My husband is a plain Jane and got a personal pepperoni pie...
Susan A.
Susan A.
I love the pizza here! I've also gotten the chicken with grilled vegetables and it was so fresh and delicious. The bread is straight from the oven....
Jackie H.
Jackie H.
I ordered food for my family, the people behind the counter were presentable and very friendly. The food, we ordered hero and a Margarita Pizza. Hero's...
Thomas D.
Thomas D.
Great place!!! If you're a fan of generic canned sauce & packaged mozz then probably not for you. Sauce is homemade & always fresh mozz. Best ingredients...
Natalie D.
Natalie D.
This place was recommended, and while I wasn't really in the mood for pizza, it was delicious! We got the vegetarian pie and the prosciutto & arugula. The personal pies are the perfect size for sharing when you want to sample a few. The food tasted... great, right down to the crust. We even got a Nutella dessert pie, which will make awesome leftovers for breakfast!The service was friendly, prompt, and mindful of covid protocol. They have a nice outdoor set up, on a side street, away from the traffic and noise out front, and our server wore a mask.I'd return when I'm in the Suffern area again.read more
Gisela S.
Gisela S.
Great food, and a great variety, they also sale wines. Great price, great costumer service!The place just rocks.
Vincent C.
Vincent C.
Excellent pizza. Always hot and delicious. I've also had the lobster ravioli which was great as well. The staff are always nice and welcoming.
Madeleine M.
Madeleine M.
Never disappointed. Friendly and attentive staff.
Christine R.
Christine R.
Can’t say enough how much I love this place. Besides the friendly, inviting atmosphere as well as staff. The owner is one of a kind. As for the food. Omg, from the pizza to the specials. Never had a bad meal. Even use them for catering. My... favorite place.read more
Deepak D.
Deepak D.
I give this place 7 star for their hospitality.
Zipster 1.
Zipster 1.
Absolutely fantastic on every level.
Ryan H.
Ryan H.
Incredible food. The owner is super nice and even went out of his way to help our local crew team fundraiser. If your looking for some pizza different than your average delivery, go here!
M M
M M
Great food! Very accommodating. They have made dishes that were not on the menu, just ask.
Allison McCoy C.
Allison McCoy C.
Always fresh, always delicious
js_loader