Reviews

4.7
Based on 182 reviews
4.9
Based on 19 reviews
4.5
Based on 94 reviews
Mr N.
Mr N.
I've tried SOOO many places here in NY trying to find a good pizza. Brooklyn, NYC, Bronx and now upstate. This is my first, and last, pizza place I will try.... I can tell you why... it's GREAT!!! I'm so spoiled by West Coast pizza but this was... awesome. First off I'd like you to see the picture of the garlic knots. Oh, wait, there is no picture because I ate them ALL before I got home!!! I could not stop. BEST GARLIC KNOTS OF ALL TIME!!! I ordered a large vegetarian pizza and when I opened the box I thought uh-oh.... thin crust... but it's really not. It was the perfect crust.... not cracker crispy but chewy the way a crust should be.... and with every bite I was extremely happy!! The toppings were fresh and plentiful. I will definitely order this again. Though next time a meat lovers pizza. The Zeppoles Were a nice finishing touch.The bottom line.... I drive 8 miles and 25 minutes to Forgia pizza, I suggest you make the effort! It is truly worth your time!!! I will return. I'm looking forward to surfing their entire menu.... because hey, if I'm stuck here in this.... ummm, hamlet, I might as well eat the very best2ND VISIT UPDATE: Ok.... I was almost hesitant to order the garlic knots again as I didn’t want to be disappointed, but I did and damnnnn if they still aren’t THE VERY BEST I’ve ever ever had! Again, gone before I arrived home. The meat lovers pizza with added heavy anchovies was almost completely destroyed as I could not stop enjoying it. I had the food baby from hell but enjoyed every minute!!Big fan!!! I’m going to try a few of their new pizzas next time.... they sound amazing too.Thank you Forgia pizza for making the weekend that fell apart soooooo much better!!!read more
Nash W.
Nash W.
Ok.... I was almost hesitant to order the garlic knots again as I didn't want to be disappointed, but I did and damnnnn if they still aren't THE VERY BEST...
Nash W.
Nash W.
I've tried SOOO many places here in NY trying to find a good pizza. Brooklyn, NYC, Bronx and now upstate. This is my first, and last, pizza place I will...
Paul M.
Paul M.
Great pizza and friendly staff and owner. Our go to Pizzeria.
Tony M.
Tony M.
Great place to eat. Takeout is good too.
Joel M.
Joel M.
I really love their dishes. I always get fantastic customer service here. The place is well kept and the staff members are always welcoming. Will come back again.
Stuart B.
Stuart B.
The pizza was excellent..!!
Kiana G.
Kiana G.
Great personal pies! Got the vegetarian and added pepperoni for spicy-ness and it was awesome! My husband is a plain Jane and got a personal pepperoni pie...
Milo B.
Milo B.
Best food, super friendly staff, constantly good vibes. They charge convenient pricing and the food quality is good. Keep it up.
Susan A.
Susan A.
I love the pizza here! I've also gotten the chicken with grilled vegetables and it was so fresh and delicious. The bread is straight from the oven....
Jackie H.
Jackie H.
I ordered food for my family, the people behind the counter were presentable and very friendly. The food, we ordered hero and a Margarita Pizza. Hero's...
Thomas D.
Thomas D.
Great place!!! If you're a fan of generic canned sauce & packaged mozz then probably not for you. Sauce is homemade & always fresh mozz. Best ingredients...
Natalie D.
Natalie D.
This place was recommended, and while I wasn't really in the mood for pizza, it was delicious! We got the vegetarian pie and the prosciutto & arugula. The personal pies are the perfect size for sharing when you want to sample a few. The food tasted... great, right down to the crust. We even got a Nutella dessert pie, which will make awesome leftovers for breakfast!The service was friendly, prompt, and mindful of covid protocol. They have a nice outdoor set up, on a side street, away from the traffic and noise out front, and our server wore a mask.I'd return when I'm in the Suffern area again.read more
Gisela S.
Gisela S.
Great food, and a great variety, they also sale wines. Great price, great costumer service!The place just rocks.
Vincent C.
Vincent C.
Excellent pizza. Always hot and delicious. I've also had the lobster ravioli which was great as well. The staff are always nice and welcoming.
Madeleine M.
Madeleine M.
Never disappointed. Friendly and attentive staff.
Christine R.
Christine R.
Can’t say enough how much I love this place. Besides the friendly, inviting atmosphere as well as staff. The owner is one of a kind. As for the food. Omg, from the pizza to the specials. Never had a bad meal. Even use them for catering. My... favorite place.read more
Deepak D.
Deepak D.
I give this place 7 star for their hospitality.
Jim M.
Jim M.
Absolutely fantastic on every level.
Ryan H.
Ryan H.
Incredible food. The owner is super nice and even went out of his way to help our local crew team fundraiser. If your looking for some pizza different than your average delivery, go here!
M M
M M
Great food! Very accommodating. They have made dishes that were not on the menu, just ask.
Allison McCoy C.
Allison McCoy C.
Always fresh, always delicious
Linda M.
Linda M.
Small, nice people and yummy food.
El S
El S
The best pizza and best food in Suffern. Thank you!
Memi M.
Memi M.
The food is great. The owners and the workers are great people.
Herman H.
Herman H.
Freshly prepared food, friendly service, great people who care about their customers. What's not to like? Took my 7 year old there and he always reminds me of how good the pizza was.
Marc G.
Marc G.
The best local pizzaria and Italian food in Suffern!
Dawn E.
Dawn E.
Tastes like authentic Italian pizza !Everything including the salad , calamari, lasagna, table bread, chicken wings and of course pizza was so delicious!...
Matt R.
Matt R.
Consistently high quality, great crust and flavorf6 sauce... And reasonably priced too. Delicious!
christina T.
christina T.
Pizza was very good
hstriker48
hstriker48
You want Italian? This guy knows how to make great Italian food in the fabulous downtown Suffern, NY.Pizza is Italian neapolitan quality and is heated by a brick wood burning oven. Italian food is great with many great original Italian sauces.... Salads are great with their fresh vegetables.Overall, a hidden gem in Suffern worthy of competing with pizza places in Brooklyn!read more
Virginia Hartmann C.
Virginia Hartmann C.
String Bean Gorgonzola Salad, and everything else on the menu.
Tom F.
Tom F.
Great Italian restaurant 🇮🇹 outdoor seating too
Anita Viccica - T.
Anita Viccica - T.
Our go to Italian food place! The people who own and work there are wonderful. The food is fresh and delicious!
Kristina Woteva H.
Kristina Woteva H.
Wonderful dinner with friends and some nice Australian Rosè
Stephanie T.
Stephanie T.
Amazing pizza, delicious penne ala vodka, and great service.
Alan W.
Alan W.
This is the original Pizza King from Mt. Vernon. Guy and his family make this like being home.....but better. Brick oven pizza is amazing but so is everything.
Mary Ellen R.
Mary Ellen R.
Love this Place Great Food & Staff is very friendly❣️
joseph D.
joseph D.
Great italian food, great service
vu345346 N.
vu345346 N.
They serve large dishes and for reasonable rates. very friendly staff. Great work.
Myra M.
Myra M.
A very nice family establishment. Get the garlic knots!
F C.
F C.
I had an excellent time at this restaurant. We enjoyed the amazing environment and the menu. The waiters are very affable. I’m glad we finally managed to eat here.
Antoinette M.
Antoinette M.
Love this place everything is good about this place.
Benjamin G.
Benjamin G.
This spot never disappoints. They serve great food for fair pricing, there no long wait even when the place is full.
Rachel F.
Rachel F.
Amazing classics
charles C.
charles C.
We had pizza & wings, both delicious, and good wine.
Marlo V.
Marlo V.
Great Food. Great prices!
Dawn W.
Dawn W.
Pizza was delicious! so good! 👍
Jennifer Kaye B.
Jennifer Kaye B.
The best combination of homemade food and lovely owners and staff. It’s a neighborhood gem.
Kathy K.
Kathy K.
The best personal pizzas around. Staff is friendly and well trained.
Brenda P.
Brenda P.
Highly recommended by a friend and we were not disappointed at all. Ambiance reminded me of old world restaurants in Italy. The sauce, oh that sauce captivated me.
Judy G.
Judy G.
Fabulous food and wonderful people. Family owned and it shows.
Larry L.
Larry L.
Exceptionally good brick oven pizza. Amazing crust. I had the white pie. I highly recommend this place.
Joan Manghisi C.
Joan Manghisi C.
The brick oven pizza is amazing. I had the frutte de mare. Lots of shrimp, clams,scungilli, mussels and calamari over linguine. The service is great and Camilla is a lovely hostess. I give it 5 stars.
Jacquelynn A.
Jacquelynn A.
Def will be going back! The bruschetta was amazing and my fiancé and I ordered a pizza was delicious �
James Evan S.
James Evan S.
Very good Sauce & Pizza crust. (That is what it is All About IMHO)
Great Wings too! Very Friendly, check em' out.
Jeanne Brady S.
Jeanne Brady S.
Wow....Really good pizza! The sauce is delicious! For me, sauce is everything and too many places just have mediocre sauce. This is fresh and light and very tasty.
Great crust too. Cooked just enough to have a crunch, but not over done. I got... onions and spinach and mushrooms (no cheese) and it was amazingly flavorful.
I will be going back! Oh, and they gave us a free bag of fresh zeppoles, too! 🙂
read more
Camille G.
Camille G.
Best pizza around. ..something about the sauce to me is different. ..we usually go every week!
Paula Gershon B.
Paula Gershon B.
Great food and the owners are really sweet. Just like going to Italy.
Rosemary B.
Rosemary B.
Loved the pizza. Waited on right away .The prices are good. Friendly atmosphere.
Juanjo Acevedo P.
Juanjo Acevedo P.
I just destroy a large pizza by myself... Yeah,is that good, really nice service, super friendly staff, u got to try it.
Jeri Simon S.
Jeri Simon S.
I was really hoping we'd like the pizza because the people were so nice and they did such a great job with the place. Turns out we loved it! And I've been recommending Forgia to people for the last two days. I'm looking forward to dining in soon,... and can't wait to see what they do with the new dining space.read more
Eileen Marie R.
Eileen Marie R.
Delicious pizza, escarole and beans...
Friendly staff; greeted warmly at the door.
Loretta K.
Loretta K.
Not easy to please the palettes of my parents (born and raised in Bari, Italy), but your pizza did! Welcome to the neighborhood, Forgia! Pizza is delicious!!!!
Mary Litensweet O.
Mary Litensweet O.
I'm addicted to it !!! Have to have it 1-2 a week
Daniel N.
Daniel N.
Omg! Words can't describe how amazing this pizza is. Definitely a must try if you live near by or far away like myself.
Jamie L.
Jamie L.
Went in and loved that they kept the old cabinetry from when this place was a luncheonette ! Ordered the NYC classic with pepperoni, and green bean salad with Gorgonzola , both are off the charts good food!! Salad is huge, enough for 4 servings !... Worth the money , every bite! Definitely a do over!read more
Andre B.
Andre B.
By far one of the best Pizza places in the area! The staff is so friendly and their service is outstanding.
Nicole R.
Nicole R.
Delicious!!! We love it! -The Suffern Chamber of Commerce
Sarah H.
Sarah H.
Delicious addition to Suffern. Personal pie for $8 can't go wrong.